Employee Share Schemes (EMIs)
Employee incentive schemes are an effective way to recruit, motivate and retain employees. They can also have the added benefit of being tax-efficient and cost effective.
An employee share scheme is a way of sharing ownership with your employees by giving them equity (shares) in the company now or an option to purchase shares in the company at a future date.
At Herrington Carmichael we have specialist EMI Scheme Lawyers who can help you. If you would like to know more about EMI Schemes or how they could work for your company then contact us online or 01276 686 222
What is a share scheme?
A share scheme is a way of founders sharing equity with employees. Equity in a company means ownership – anyone who holds shares in a company owns part of the company (and therefore its assets).
There are many different forms of share scheme, but they all work in one of two ways:
Equity now – employees are given actual shares in the company now
Equity later – employees are granted an option which gives them a right to purchase shares in the company at a certain point in the future (at an agreed price)
Why set up an employee share scheme?
There are many benefits associated with shared employee ownership for businesses. The most common reasons we see employers wanting to set up schemes include:
- Recruitment of top talent, particularly when the recruitment market is tough
- Retention of the best talent
- Creation of an ownership culture amongst employees
- To motivate employees to improve their performance and productivity
- Reward employees (similar to a cash bonus scheme)
- To keep up with competitor firms in the industry
Which type of share scheme is right for my business?
The best share scheme for a business will depend on its size, industry, employees and motivations for implementing a scheme. Some examples of recent share schemes we have helped clients with include:
Company 1: start-up business where the founder shareholder brought in an employee who he wanted to motivate to grow the business with the aim of a sale in 8-10 years. We assisted the company in obtaining a valuation for EMI purposes from HMRC of £1 per share. EMI options were granted to the employee who can exercise them on a sale of the company.
Company 2: a founder shareholder wanted to reduce his shareholding over time for personal tax planning reasons and to pass on ownership to employees. The company did not qualify for EMI due to operating an excluded trade but did qualify for a CSOP scheme. Some employees were family members so did not qualify for beneficial tax treatment of CSOPs, but instead received unapproved options.
Company 3: company had an existing EMI scheme exercisable by employees on a sale of the company. The shareholders decided they wanted some longstanding overseas employees and consultants to also benefit from the sale. Immediately prior to sale, those employees and consultants were granted unapproved options which were exercised on the sale.
Company 4: company currently valued at £11m wanted to motivate its management team to participate in the future growth of the business. The management team were issued with growth shares which only entitle them to a return on any amounts in excess of £11m when the company is sold.
Why should startups offer equity?
Share schemes can be equally, if not more, beneficial to startups with few employees than to large companies with many employees. Setting up a share scheme early on can assist with:
- Ownership mentality
- Recruitment & retention
Request a call or a meeting in person with one of our Share Scheme solicitors...
Employee share schemes (EMIs) FAQs
What is the difference between a "share scheme" and an "option scheme"?
A share scheme is a way to give employees actual shares in the company today. An option scheme gives employees the right to exercise their option and receive shares in the company at a certain point in the future e.g. when they hit a certain performance target or when the company is sold.
What are the different types of share schemes?
There are various types of scheme, some of which are suited to larger companies and some more suited to small companies or start-ups with only two or three founders.
Four of the available schemes are “approved” by HMRC which means that they are tax-efficient for the employees receiving shares/options. These are:
- Enterprise Management Incentives (EMIs)
- Company Share Option Plans (CSOPs)
- Share Incentive Plans (SIPs)
- Save As You Earn (SAYE)
EMIs are probably the most popular, particularly with start-ups and in IT / technology industries. Other schemes are “unapproved” and are potentially not as tax-efficient. These include:
- Growth shares
- Unapproved share options
- Employee ownership trusts
- Nil paid shares
How to set up an EMI Scheme
If you are a founder of a startup or an early-stage business and are thinking about sharing equity with your team, we can help you explore the different options available and implement your chosen scheme. If you would to discuss further, please contact Yavan Brar and Emma Roper in our Corporate team.
Employee Share Schemes Team
- All departments
- Agricultural Law
- Co Co - Employee Share Schemes
- Co Co - Recovery & Insolvency
- Co Co - Restructuring
- Co Co Corporate Governance
- Co Co Corporate lending
- Co Co Financial Services
- Co Co Franchising
- Co Co GDPR
- Co Co in-house legal support
- Co Co International Contracts
- Co Co M&A's
- Co Co MBOs & MBIs
- Co Co Partnership and LLPs
- Co Co Regulatory, Compliance & Competition
- Co Co Shareholders Agreements
- Co Co Terms and Conditions
- Co Co- Intellectual Property
- CoCo - Banking and Finance
- CoCo - New Businsess
- CoCo Competition Law
- CoCo Consumer Law
- CoCo Data Protection - Marketing
- CoCo Data, IT & Technology
- Commercial Law
- Commercial Property
- Corporate & Commercial
- Corporate Law
- Debt Recovery
- Dispute Resolution
- Disputes - Business
- Disputes - Declarations of trust
- Disputes - Probate and inheritance
- Disputes - Professional negligence
- Disputes - Restrictive Covenants
- Disputes - Shareholders & Partnership
- Disputes - Tenants in Residential Property
- Disputes - Wills, trusts & probate disputes
- Disputes and Small Claims
- Disputes Construction
- Disputes with Co-owners
- Employee - Termination
- Employer - Termination
- Employment - Business protection
- Employment - Collective consultations
- Employment - Contracts, services, consultancy
- Employment - Employee benefits
- Employment - Employee Procedures
- Employment - Equality, discrimination and harassment
- Employment - Family Friendly Rights
- Employment - GDPR and Data Protection
- Employment - Post employment obligations
- Employment - Redundancy & Reorganisation
- Employment - Settlement Agreements
- Employment - Tribunal Claims
- Employment - TUPE
- Employment - Wages, holiday and sick pay
- Employment - Workers rights
- Employment Tribunal claims
- Estate Administration
- Expat Legal Services
- Family Law
- Financial Services
- Help to Buy
- Immigration law
- International Legal Services
- Key Property Contacts
- Land and Property Disputes
- Land, development and construction
- Lasting Powers of Attorney
- Licensing Law
- Money, Tax and Inheritance
- New Build Conveyancing
- Private Wealth and Inheritance
- Professional Negligence
- Property Finance
- Property Law
- Residential Property
- Residential Property - Completions
- Residential Property - Shared Ownership
- Trainee Solicitor
- Wills, Trusts & Probate
“My experience with Herrington Carmichael has been first-class. The advice, guidance and support from Emma and Yavan was excellent, resulting in a swift and decisive project conclusion. Highly recommended.”
This podcast will help businesses to avoid filing mistakes that can be costly further down the line and have a negative impact on the company.
ACAS has given advice encouraging employers to consider a degree of flexibility over the World Cup period.
This month’s episode will be an overview of sponsor licences and the process of obtaining a sponsor licence for businesses.
Set Up of EMI Options
Advising on the set up of EMI and unapproved options for national and overseas employees of a tech company and dealing with the exercise of the options on the subsequent multi-million pound sale of the business
Set Up of CSOP for Agricultural Company
Advising on the set up of a CSOP scheme for 15 employees of an agricultural business which did not qualify for an EMI scheme
Set Up of EMI for Start-up
Set up of an EMI scheme for a start-up estate agency to motivate employees to grow the business with the aim of a sale in 8-10 years
Growth Share Scheme for Finance Company
Creation of a growth share scheme for a client in the financial services industry to motivate the management team to participate in the future growth of the business
Herrington Carmichael has been advising families and businesses for over 175 years. We provide an increasingly specialist legal practice – we offer a wide range of services, beyond that of a traditional private client firm to meet the demands of our UK and international clients.
Award winning legal advice
We are solicitors in Camberley, Wokingham and London. In 2019, Herrington Carmichael won ‘Property Law Firm of the Year’ at the Thames Valley Business Magazines Property Awards, ‘Best Medium Sized Business’ at the Surrey Heath Business Awards and we were named IR Global’s ‘Member of the Year’. We are ranked as a Leading Firm 2023 by Legal 500 and Alistair McArthur is ranked in Chambers 2022.